|
MOBILE DEVICES AS AN INSTRUMENT |
MOBILITY AS AN INDUSTRY |
| Connectivity |
How affordable and widespread are mobile devices for the
common citizen? |
Does the country have manufacturing industries for hardware,
software, mobile solutions and services? |
| Content |
Is there useful content (foreign and local) for citizens to use in
their daily lives on mobile devices? |
Is content being generated in local languages and localised
interfaces? Is this being accessed/used abroad? |
| Community |
Are there online/offline forums where citizens can discuss
mobile services and other issues of concern? |
Is the country a hub of discussion and forums for the worldwide mobile
industry? |
| Commerce |
Is there infrastructure (tech, legal) for m-commerce for
citizens, businesses and government? How much commerce is transacted
electronically? |
Does the country have indigenous m-commerce technology and services? Are
these being exported? |
| Capacity |
Do citizens and organisations have the human resources capacity (tech,
managerial, policy, legal) to effectively harness mobile devices for daily
use? |
Does the country have the human resources capacity (tech, managerial,
policy, legal) to create and export mobile devices and services, and set
standards? |
| Culture |
Is there a forward-looking, open, progressive culture at the level
of policymakers, businesses, educators, citizens and the media in
opening up access to wireless spectrum and mobile devices and
harnessing them? Or is there nervousness and phobia about the cultural
and political impacts of ICTs? |
Are there techies, entrepreneurs and managers pro-active and savvy enough to
create local companies in mobility and take them global? |
| Cooperation |
Is there adequate cooperation between citizens, businesses,
academics, NGOs and policymakers to create a favourable climate for
using mobile devices? |
Is there a favourable regulatory environment in the country for creating
mobile device/service companies, M&A activity, and links with the diaspora
population? |
| Capital |
Are there enough financial resources to invest in wireless
infrastructure and education? What is the level of FDI? |
Is there a domestic venture capital industry; are they investing
abroad as well? How many international players are active in the local
private equity market? Are there stock markets for public listing? |
|
|
|
Financial Content and Services
The operating environment in developing countries
presents unique opportunities for mobile-based financial services, an optimal
combination of necessity on the demand side and solid upside on the supply side,
according to a recent Pyramid Research report. Payment models are driven by
operators, banks, hybrid alliances or third party platform providers.
Mobile banking technologies are powered by SMS, USSD
(Unstructured Supplementary Service Data), WAP, Java and SIM toolkits. Players
in this space in Africa include M-PESA (Kenya, Tanzania), MTN (South Africa,
Nigeria), Celpay (Zambia), MoneyTextMe (Ghana), Sokotele (Kenya) and WIZZIT
(South Africa).
The independent Consultative Group to Assist the Poor
(CGAP), a World Banksupported research centre, has identified mobile phone
banking as an important tool in Africa, Asia and Latin America. The current
global financial crisis makes the need for widespread availability of safe
alternatives to cash even more pressing.
Global mobile subscriptions surpassed four billion at
year-end 2008 and are expected to approach six billion by 2013, making mobile
services an extremely relevant platform for advertising and transactions for
mass audiences.
Compliance with banking regulations and security of the
networks have been cited as the major challenges in operating mobile money
transfer services in developing countries.
Only one in five African households in African has
access to a bank account, according to the United Nations, but a much higher
proportion have a mobile phone and many operators hope offering financial
services will attract new customers.
Some 175 million migrants currently use remittance
services, sending money to around 800 million dependent recipients, according to
the GSM Association. Remittance flows have reached USD 320 billion and are
estimated to reach USD 700 billion by 2012.
Uptake of mobile technology for banking services is set
to hit 900 million users worldwide by 2014, according to analyst Berg Insight.
The predictions indicate a compound annual growth rate of 89 per cent from the
20 million users using mobile channels in 2008, with Asia being the fastest
growing market and representing about 65 per cent of users.
Mobile technology will therefore play an important role
in bringing financial services to people in the Middle East and Africa who do
not use bank accounts. "Mobile handsets are in an excellent position to become
the primary digital channel for providers of banking and related financial
services on emerging markets," according to Berg Insight telecom analyst Marcus
Persson.
Juniper Research forecasts the average revenue
opportunity for carriers, for both national and international mobile money
transfers combined (based on estimated commission levels that they will be able
to charge), is in excess of $5 billion by 2013.
Mobile Healthcare
"Mobiles are increasingly the computers of the future
and now emerging countries are getting on board rapidly, argues health education
specialist Inge de Waard. Continuing Medical Education (CME) is becoming
possible also in developing countries thanks to mobile phones.
"We can reach physicians in the field to deliver
lifelong learning. Keeping physicians in contact with peers will enhance
knowledge exchange in priority settings. Getting the latest medical information
out there is crucial, and mobile access to medical Websites or peer to peer
knowledge exchange networks is important," she argues.
Success factors include accessibility to medical
content via cheap phones, receiving relevant alerts on time, and providing
certification for medical education modules. Challenges remain, of course, since
graphics and tables are sometimes unclear on small screens, and battery life can
interrupt long education sessions.
Maryland-based communications firm Danya International
has used mobile video-enabled phones in meeting the requirements for monitoring
medication adherence by tuberculosis (TB) patients during the 3rd East African
Health and Scientific Conference. The Mobile Direct Observation Treatment (MDOT)
Pilot Project received high positive ratings from the patients and health care
workers who participated.
"Mobile phone technology offers opportunities to expand
and enhance medical treatment where direct observation of patients is required,"
according to Danya CEO Jeffrey Hoffman.
The MDOT Pilot Project follows the experiences of 13 TB
patients, their patient assistants, and health care workers over a 30-day period
in Nairobi, Kenya. Patients were provided a mobile phone capable of sending and
receiving video and text messages. Patients and their assistants video-captured
the patient taking their prescribed dose of TB medication in their home and
immediately transmitted it to a central database where health care workers
viewed the video to assure compliance with the DOT protocol.
Patients also received health messages in video and
text formats on their mobile phones. At the end of one month, the participants
completed a brief questionnaire on their experiences. Participants expressed
satisfaction with the procedures and the use of the mobile phone technology for
remote medication monitoring, health education, and communication.
Other partners who supported the MDOT Pilot Project
were Safaricom, Nokia Siemens Networks and EPOS Health Consultants.
Project Masiluleke, a mobile health project in South
Africa, is using cell phone text messages to reach people in even the most
remote areas of the country to encourage them to get information and counseling
on HIV/AIDS.
The project delivers about 1 million HIV/AIDS and
tuberculosis texts each day to personal cell phones providing the number for the
national AIDS helpline along with messages like: "Frequently sick, tired, losing
weight and scared that you might be HIV positive? Please call AIDS
Helpline."
Since the program began in fall of 2008, the messages
have increased calls to the center from about 1,000 a day to between 3,000 and
4,000 a day, according to Gustav Praekelt of the Praekelt Foundation, which
designed the technology behind the project.
"Increasingly in Africa we find that the mobile phone
is the prime resource for finding information," according to Praekelt. "I think
people often underestimate the penetration of these devices in Africa and what a
difference it makes to a lot of people's lives."
Callers to the national helpline can ask questions
about HIV, get information about where to get tested and receive counseling.
The project takes advantage of a popular form of
texting across Africa, called a "please call me" message, that can be sent for
free from a phone even if it is out of pre-paid minutes. The empty characters on
the free text are used to convey the health message.
Future phases of the project will allow users to text
health questions, if they prefer not to call the line, and will provide an
internet portal of information accessible by cell phone for people to learn
about HIV. The ultimate goal, says the group, would be to provide free home HIV
testing kits that would be supported by mobile counseling, so that people who
aren't willing to visit a clinic can find out their status.
Zinny Thabethe, an HIV positive South African and
co-founder of the HIV/AIDS education organization iTeach, helped create the
program for Project Masiluleke. She said opening a dialogue about HIV/AIDS is so
important because the stigma surrounding HIV/AIDS in South Africa is still very
strong.
An estimated 18 percent of South Africans between the
ages of 15 and 49 are HIV positive, according to the World Health Organization.
"Because [the helpline] is confidential and anonymous
they can phone in and talk to someone who doesn't know them, who is in another
province, who can help them with their questions and they can be able to be
honest," according to Thabethe. South Africa has 13 official languages, and the
project sends messages in the major vernaculars.
Aside from initiatives for health outreach and
education like Project Masiluleke, there are also pilot programs around the
world working on monitoring patients and reminding them to take medications,
using mobile technology to quickly collect data about outbreaks so that proper
medical response can be deployed faster, and using mobile technology to connect
health workers with the training and support they need.
In a world first in HIV education, Metropolitan Life
one of South Africa's largest insurance companies has partnered with CellBook to
present an information booklet on HIV and AIDS which can be downloaded onto a
cellphone. Called "B the Future," the social initiative can potentially reach
over 30 million mobile phone users.
"We want to educate South Africans to know their status
and take personal responsibility for managing their health," says actuary Nathea
Nicolay, Metropolitan AIDS Risk Consulting Manager. "If we are going to beat
this epidemic, we need a widespread behaviour change. B the Future aims to
educate people on how to live positively and also to prevent new infections."
In order to ensure that the information is accessible
to everyone, not just those with the latest cellphones, the information has been
compressed to below 300 kb so that the entire book can be easily and quickly
sent in a single transaction to a mobile phone
"At only R1 per SMS, it is affordable and takes less
time than it would to download a ringtone. SMS the word HIV to 32907 and you'll
get back everything you need to know about HIV and AIDS," explains Bertus
Preller, Marketing Executive for CellBook.
Claire Thwaites, who heads the U.N. Foundation's work
on mHealth, said the mobile phone technology is already in the hands of 64
percent of people in the developing world, and that number continues to
grow.
In Europe, the European Commission has developed a
system that alerts public health officials to potential threats by sorting
information from news websites. The MediSys system provides European health
authorities with real-time information on developing health hazards such as
disease outbreaks or industrial accidents.
The system reportedly collects and sorts data from more
than 1,000 news websites and 120 public health sites in 32 languages -- and uses
e-mail and SMS to automatically alert health officials, giving them timely
warnings of possible hazards.
By 2012, 50 percent of all individuals in remote areas
of the world are expected to have mobile phones. But the field of mhealth
technology needs to be strengthened by rigorous data collection about results
before programs can be expanded.
Mobile Education
While the evidence base is still quite spotty, usage
models are slowly emerging from m-education pilot projects in places as diverse
as Thailand and Mongolia, observes education specialist Michael Trucano. The
increasing ubiquity of mobile phones has helped enabled pilots looking at mobile
gaming to support literacy in India. Even the World Bank has reportedly got into
the act, through Development Marketplace funding for a small pilot in
Bangladesh.
Perhaps the most well known, and biggest, of these
pilot programs is the text2teach project in the Philippines (see video at the
top of this blog post), which provides a way for teachers to request educational
videos via text message, with the videos delivered to a television at the school
via satellite.
Canada's Althabasca University has just published a
general survey on Mobile Learning: Transforming the Delivery of Education and
Training. Many educational mobile learning uses have been explored: from
low-cost mass learning opportunities through SMS, to edutainment, to data
gathering (surveys, exams, questionnaires) to administrative and learning
support, with very different mobile devices.
Mobile Agriculture and Trade The mobile phone has
played an important role in transforming agricultural marketplaces via
quantitative analysis.
The Cambodia Crop Production and Marketing Project
(CCPMP) has the overarching aim of improving agricultural value chains as a key
to sustainable growth and poverty reduction in Western Cambodia. Using mobile
technology, the project facilitates the sharing of knowledge and information at
all stages of the value chain from farmer to end-user, delivering practical
benefits including improved food security, increased income, and reduced
vulnerability to disruptions for rural poor farmers.
DrumNet is a pilot project by rural farmers in central
Kenya, which provides marketing, financial services and information via their
mobile phones. The premise of the Pride Africa project is that a lack of market
information is one of the key elements that keeps farmers from getting the full
market value for their products.
"As the information flow increases due to the mobile
phone coverage expansion, the cost of crop marketing is expected to decrease,
particularly more so for perishable crops, such as banana, in remote areas
because the increased information allows traders to collect perishable products
more efficiently," according to Megumi Muto and T. Yamano, in a paper called
"The impact of mobile phone coverage expansion on market participation: Panel
data evidence from Uganda".
Traders use mobile phones to set up a time and place to
trade banana", whereas in the absence of mobiles they just arrive unannounced
and buy what's available, waiting until their trucks are full.
On a broader scale, CellBazaar is a service from
Grameenphone that allows people to buy or sell over their mobile phones.
Customers looking to sell something, post the information on CellBazaar through
Grameenphone, and buyers get in contact. Customers looking to buy something, or
to use someone's services (e.g., tutor), look for it on CellBazaar and contact
the seller directly. When buyers sees items they like, they can call the seller,
get additional information, and arrange to meet the seller to complete the
transaction. CellBazaar is a platform for buyers and sellers to find each
other.
Manobi is a wireless e-service assisting Senegalese
fishermen in the marketing of their catch. The Manobi Development
Foundation has a much wider remit and operates in the US, France, Senegal and
South Africa. Generally, the service allows traders to receive market prices and
make trades via SMS. Consumers and restaurants are encouraged to use the service
to find and purchase goods from farmers at bid pricing.
The Trade At Hand initiative of the International Trade
Centre (ITC) has two modules: MarketPrices and MarketAlerts. MarketPrices uses
text messages in order to inform exporters in developing economies about the
daily changes in the international price of their export of interest. A module
called MarketAlerts enables local trade support institutions to build more
efficient networks of exporters by transmitting information to them about
business opportunities and market
news.
Mobiles and Social Inclusion
Mobile
phones have been distributed to cooperative women's farming groups in different
agro-ecological zones in Maseru district, western Lesotho, by the Regional
Hunger and Vulnerability Programme (RHVP), which builds evidence to help
policy-makers working on food security and social protection.
"The phone has transformed the women farmers' lives
completely - they are able to market their produce, access information on
prices, and it has made them so confident," according to Gladys Faku, national
chairman of the Participatory Ecological Land Use Management (PELUM), a network
of NGOs and civil society groups working with small-scale farmers in East,
Central and Southern Africa.
RHVP ran the project as part of a pilot programme to
see how vulnerable people benefit from cellphones, to disprove arguments against
the use of mobile phones for cash transfers, and to prove that illiterate people
are able to embrace technology.
"The pilot also took a step further to prove that not
only are illiterate people able to handle technology, but also benefit from
improved communications, both in terms of their farming activities and the
reduced time and cost of staying in touch with each other," said Katharine
Vincent of RHVP.
The women managed to use the mobile phones as a tool to
generate income by selling airtime on their phones, and extended their mobile
network by using the money from selling airtime to purchase more phones. One of
the groups also used the money to buy piglets, which were sold to generate more
money.
Saving in time and travel costs have also been realised
in mountainous Lesotho, which has enormous distances and a poor public transport
system. In Maseru district in western Lesotho, the distance between cooperative
groups can be up to 200km - a 16-hour round trip by taxi costing about $13, with
an overnight stay.
However, Richard Heeks, director of Manchester
University's Centre for Development, cautions: "We talked a few years back about
the 'digital divide', now we are recognising the mobile divide."
In a study of a group of workers in Nigeria's informal
cloth-weaving sector, it was found that weavers without a mobile were forced to
go on costly and sometimes dangerous journeys, making it increasingly hard to
obtain orders.
Along with the contribution mobiles can make to
securing livelihoods, they are also important in reducing the vulnerabilities
that people face as a result of lack of information and isolation, according to
Abi Jagun from Strathclyde University's Department of Management
Science.
Mobile Content in Developing Countries: The Road
Ahead
Mobile users in developing countries express a stronger
desire for content and advanced features, according to a "Global Mobile Mindset
Audit" study released by the Forum to Advance the Mobile Experience (FAME), part
of the CMO Council and Global Market Insight (GMI), and sponsored by
Palm.
U.S. users lag most behind other countries in terms of
accessing the Web, or wanting access, using cellular phones. In the U.S., 22.6
percent find the feature important or very important. Other countries exhibit
higher demand: Western Europe (30.4 percent); Eastern Europe (53.9 percent);
Asia (56.4 percent); and Latin America (63.5 percent).
"The difference between developing countries and the
U.S. and Western Europe really is played out throughout the survey in terms of
advanced services and how interested users are in accessing them," according to
Dave Murray, director of the CMO Council's FAME Group.
In some cases, mobile services can compensate for a
lack of infrastructure in phone and Internet services, as well as in other
areas. One example Murray cites is a demand for mobile network banking
access.
"In India there is a lack of an established consumer
ATM network," accrording to Murray. "The idea of a lack of infrastructure goes
beyond communications, lack of infrastructure in banking, commerce, and
entertainment, which is leaving users in developing countries to rely more
heavily on mobile devices."
A dotMobi Advisory Group has been formed to assess
market requirements, localisation strategies, business models, funding
approaches, and best practice recommendations for developing countries using
.mobi domains and solutions.
The Task Force has now agreed to create a sub-group to
contribute specifically towards a prototype for the World Digital Library
(http://www.worlddigitallibrary.org), as part of the wider content delivery strategy to developing
countries with mobile content delivery being one of the key vehicles to
achieving this.
Madanmohan Rao is the editor of "Asia
Unplugged" and Director - Research, Digital Empowerment Foundation. He can be
reached at madan@techsparks.com